December 01, 2020 3 min read

Don’t Call It a Comeback, Reel to Reels Still Run Circles Around Vinyl

Reel-to-reel tape players have been around for over a century, with the original models appearing on the scene in the late 1800s. Their popularity grew in the 1940s and 1950s, when the manufacturing process was perfected.  From then until fairly recently in the history of audio recording, they were the music industry standard for making master recordings. From the 1950s until as late as the early 1980s, reel-to-reel decks were the centerpiece of most home entertainment systems.  

But when advancements in digital audio shot to new heights in the late 1980s, tape decks quickly lost their appeal with professionals and hobbyists alike.  The simplicity of cassettes, and eventually, the quality and convenience of digital recordings, killed-off reel-to-reel…or so it was thought.

The reel-to-reel deck became a ‘vintage’ item, much like the humble vinyl record; costly machines ended-up in dumpsters and pawn shops, but never quite disappeared. Stubborn audiophiles, old school radio stations and record producers like Steve Albini and Rick Rubin continued to champion their analog virtues in a digital world. 

Looking for a great player? See Our Ultimate Guide to Reel to Reel Players

 Akai reel to reel player

The Resurgence

The true reason tape survived wasn’t because analog-obsessed audiophiles, notorious for embracing dated technologies, held onto a bittersweet longing for something of the past, but because the fact remained that tape is an incredibly dense archival medium that has never been improved upon

The resurrection started about a decade ago, when refurbished reel-to-reels started reappearing at hi-fi shows. Incredibly, the audio world started seeing a resurgence of the decks that had declined only decades ago. 

As audiophiles and music lovers around the world continued to argue whether hi-res digital actually made a perceivable difference, one thing remained clear: the analog resurgence was growing.

The Sound Quality Is As Good As It Gets

In 2013, The Absolute Sound shocked readers by proclaiming that a new reel-to-reel deck designed by a team of fanatic engineers absolutely crushed the highest-rated turntable-based system ever reviewed by the magazine. “I have never heard rock and roll reproduced more powerfully and realistically in my home or at a show in my entire life,” concluded reviewer Jonathan Valin. The deck in question was billed as ‘new’ but was in fact a highly modified TASCAM Pro deck.

Fast forward to today and the resale market of vintage machines is seeing strong and steady growth, as more and more music lovers rediscover what a core of audiophiles never forgot; you just can’t top analog sound quality (there are currently 8,107 "Reel to Reel" related eBay listings, and the online auction house has posted a guide for prospective buyers).  

Although vinyl and turntable sales are currently shooting through the roof, analog-loving audiophiles know that reel-to-reel has inherent advantages over the once-again-hot vinyl record, because quite simply the sound quality is as good as it gets. 

Better Than Vinyl? 

This is the prevailing question. Tape or vinyl? Even the most dubious critics have no doubt. The answer: tape sounds better than vinyl. Period. Not the cassette tapes of the Walkman era or those 8-track bricks; those cheap technologies are an affront to tape.

Analog vs vinyl

We hope you've enjoyed this post on why tape is better than vinyl. For a guide on where to find quality pre-recorded music on R2R tape check out our blog post here. 

RX Reels prides ourselves on manufacturing the world's best carbon fiber reels. Learn more about us and why Soundstage!HIFI's Ken Kessler has said "The RX Reels are among the mechanically best I’ve ever seen. In use they provide the most even take-up I’ve experienced."

You Might Also Enjoy: The Best Pre-Owned Reel to Reel Players 

People Found This Post By Searching:

  • reel to reel vs vinyl 
  • reel to reel tape players 
  • reel to reel buyers guide
  • history of reel to reel tape players 
  • music production 
  • vinyl for sale 
  • reel to reel players for sale 
  • digital vs analog 
  • sounds quality reel to reel vs vinyl
  • r2r vs vinyl
  • reel to reel music 
  • best reel to reel tape  
Kevin Root
Kevin Root



Also in Reel News

10" reel to reel player for open reel tape
Pro-Tips: Reel to Reel Buying, Playing & Optimizing the Tape Experience

October 03, 2022 9 min read

We get asked a lot of questions about reel to reel players. These range from how to buy one to recording, playback and the maintenance of both tapes and decks. We thought it would be helpful to assemble a list of tips and suggestions from our reel to reel community as well as some notable experts around the industry.
RX Reels’ prototype 7-inch carbon fiber reel for open reel tape players
Ken Kessler's Review of RX Reels 7 inch Carbon Fiber Reel

September 22, 2022 7 min read

Running a finger over the spooled tape reveals no unevenness, no ridges. It made me think of (and I compared them to) fresh blank tape as it arrived from the factory. For this alone, anyone who uses 7-inch spools on a regular basis should purchase at least one for critical playback of treasured tapes.
UKRAINE REFUGEE FUNDRAISER - THANK YOU TO ALL WHO DONATED!
UKRAINE REFUGEE FUNDRAISER - THANK YOU TO ALL WHO DONATED!

April 29, 2022 1 min read

Our final donation to the World Central Kitchen to help feed the Ukrainian Refugees after transaction fees came to $6,035.85. Thank you so much to everyone who donated!

We had over 300 $20 donation/raffle tickets purchased by over 100 different people from 8 different countries!